Carl sang beautifully when he had the chance. And he had the chance often. He sang gospel, and he practiced regularly. He sang with his church choir, but he also sang in a private group of friends on Friday nights. They sang anthems and hymns, but they also sang their own songs a Capella style. Since he sang together with other people he did not feel shy. However, he sang with such a nice voice, that singing solo was also possible for him, although he didn’t know it.