Back to Blog

Stop Trying Harder at English Learning: The Silly Repetition Method That Actually Works

My student was practicing shadowing.

Concentrating SO hard.

Face tense. Jaw locked. Getting worse with each attempt.

I told her: "Stop trying so hard. Just be dumb about it."

She looked at me like I was crazy.

Then she tried it.

Breakthrough.

What Is Procedural Memory?

Procedural Memory
The type of memory that controls skills and habits—like riding a bike or typing. You don't think about HOW to do it. Your body just knows. Language rhythm works the same way.

Why Does Trying Harder Make Things Worse?

The Tension Problem

When you concentrate too hard, your body responds:

Physical Effect Result
Tongue gets stiff Can't form sounds smoothly
Jaw locks Blocks natural movement
Throat tightens Restricts airflow
Muscles tense Destroys fluid motion

It's like trying to write with a clenched fist.

The harder you try, the worse it gets.

That's the paradox.

What Happens in Your Brain

High-pressure thinking:

  • Activates analytical brain regions
  • Creates muscle tension
  • Blocks procedural learning
  • Makes you self-conscious
  • Results in worse performance

Low-pressure repetition:

  • Activates procedural brain regions
  • Relaxes muscles naturally
  • Enables automatic learning
  • Removes self-consciousness
  • Results in better performance

How Does Silly Repetition Remove Pressure?

The "Be Dumb About It" Approach

Here's what I told my student:

"Just say it twenty times. Don't think. Just repeat like a parrot."

Key elements:

  • Mindlessly repeat
  • No goal of "getting it right"
  • Just do it, don't analyze it
  • Remove all judgment
  • Make it silly on purpose

Sounds dumb?

That's the point.

Your brain learns procedurally, not analytically.

Thinking blocks the learning.

What Is the Bike Riding Analogy?

Think about learning to ride a bike:

What Doesn't Work What Works
Studying balance equations Getting on the bike
Reading about physics Falling down
Understanding theory Getting up
Analyzing the mechanics Trying again
Thinking about it Just doing it

Result: Eventually your body figures it out.

Zero thinking required.

Language rhythm works exactly the same way.

The Parallel

Bike Riding Language Rhythm
Muscle memory Muscle memory
No conscious thought No conscious thought
Body learns by doing Body learns by doing
Can't explain how Can't explain how
Just works Just works

Why Does Low-Pressure Practice Work Better?

The Learning Speed Difference

3 Intense Repetitions 20 Silly Repetitions
High tension Low tension
Trying to "get it right" Not trying, just doing
Self-conscious Unselfconscious
Slower learning Faster learning
Still frustrating Nearly perfect

The equation:

  • No judgment = No tension
  • No tension = Natural muscle movement
  • Natural movement = Correct sounds
  • Correct sounds = Successful learning

What Happened with My Student

After 20 "dumb" repetitions:

  • She nailed it perfectly
  • I asked her how
  • She said: "I don't know. I just stopped thinking."

Exactly right.

That's procedural memory taking over.

Her brain learned the pattern without conscious effort.

Why Do Students Resist This Approach?

Common Objections

Students resist because:

  1. "It feels too simple"

    • They expect learning to be complex
    • Simple = not "real" learning in their minds

  2. "Just repeating won't help me understand"

    • But understanding isn't the goal during practice
    • Production is the goal

  3. "I need to know WHY it sounds like that"

    • Not during practice
    • Understanding can come later (or never)
    • Native speakers don't know why either

The Real Problem

What Students Want What Actually Works
Understand first, then practice Practice first, understanding optional
Think their way to fluency Do their way to fluency
Learn by analyzing Learn by repeating
Complex methods Simple repetition

They've been taught that learning requires understanding.

But procedural memory doesn't work that way.

What Permission Do Students Need?

The Three Permissions

Students need explicit permission to:

  1. Sound stupid

    • Remove the fear of judgment
    • Make silly sounds okay
    • Normalize imperfection

  2. Repeat mindlessly

    • Stop trying to understand during practice
    • Just do it like a parrot
    • Remove the thinking requirement

  3. NOT understand while practicing

    • Separate practice from analysis
    • Allow learning without comprehension
    • Trust the process

Result when pressure is removed: Learning happens naturally.

How Can You Apply This Tomorrow?

The Step-by-Step Process

Step 1: Choose one sentence

  • Keep it simple
  • Make it achievable
  • Focus on pronunciation/rhythm

Step 2: Give clear instructions

Say to students: "Don't try to understand it. Just repeat it twenty times like a parrot."

Step 3: Expect resistance

  • "But shouldn't I know WHY?"
  • "This seems too simple"
  • "I need to understand first"

Step 4: Push through

  • Reassure them it's okay
  • Keep them repeating
  • Don't allow analysis

Step 5: Watch the breakthrough

  • After twenty times: They get it
  • They won't know how
  • That's the magic

Action Steps for This Week

Try this low-pressure drill:

  1. Pick one sentence from your curriculum
  2. Tell students: "We're going to be dumb about this"
  3. Have them repeat 20 times mindlessly
  4. No analysis allowed
  5. No "understanding" required
  6. Just repeat like a parrot

What to observe:

  • Resistance at first (they want to "understand")
  • Gradual relaxation of facial muscles
  • Improvement around repetition 10-12
  • Near-perfect by repetition 20
  • Surprise that it worked

Key Takeaways

  • Trying Harder Creates Tension: Tense muscles can't produce smooth sounds
  • Thinking Blocks Learning: Procedural memory doesn't need analytical understanding
  • Silly = Effective: Low-pressure repetition works better than intense concentration
  • Permission Required: Students need explicit permission to not understand
  • Twenty Times = Pattern: Neural pathways strengthen through repetition
  • Bike Riding Principle: You learn by doing, not by thinking about doing
  • Best Learners Try Dumber: Not harder—more repetition, less analysis

Why This Changes Everything

When students learn this approach:

  1. Practice becomes easier

    • Less stressful
    • More productive
    • Actually enjoyable

  2. Results come faster

    • Neural pathways strengthen quickly
    • Skills become automatic
    • Confidence builds naturally

  3. Learning becomes sustainable

    • No burnout from over-thinking
    • Can practice longer without exhaustion
    • Creates positive feedback loop

The best learners don't try harder.

They try dumber.

More repetition. Less thinking.

More doing. Less analyzing.

This is how children learn their first language.

And it's how your students should learn English too.

Give them permission to be silly.

To repeat mindlessly.

To stop trying so hard.

The breakthrough comes when they stop thinking.

Try it.

You'll see.